British oil firm EnQuest Plc's shares slumped to a three-year low on March 12 after Cairn Energy Plc, its partner in its flagship Kraken project, cut its estimate of the oil field's reserves by around a fifth.
The Kraken oil and gas field in the British North Sea is EnQuest's largest producing asset. EnQuest holds around a 70% stake and Cairn owns the rest.
Cairn said in a statement that it had revised down its estimate of Kraken's reserves by 19%, or 6.8 million barrel of oil equivalent (boe).
"Gross production from Kraken averaged 30,300 boe/d in 2018, which was below expectations," Cairn said. "Production levels were most significantly affected by production system outages on the FPSO, weather-related incidents and higher water-cut than originally expected."
A shutdown is expected later this year, it added.
EnQuest, however, said its estimate of Kraken's reserves was "materially unchanged" given the two companies use different types of analyses and that it foresaw no impairment charges on Kraken. Cairn said it had booked a charge of $163 million on Kraken on the back of the downgrade.
The conflicting reports added to pressure on EnQuest's share price, which fell to a three-year low of 16.08 pence before recovering some losses. They were down around 9% at 16.80 pence at 5:37 a.m. CST (10:37 GMT).
"The companies utilize different technical approaches to Kraken production forecasting in preparing their reserve profiles for their respective auditors. However, this additional uncertainty is unwelcome," RBC analyst Al Stanton said.
EnQuest switched from plans to sell a 20% stake in Kraken to borrowing money against it after two sets of sale talks had to be abandoned as a deadline for a debt repayment approached, industry and banking sources said last year.
Instead, EnQuest decided to borrow $175 million against 15% of Kraken's cash flow from Oz (Och-Ziff) Management to be paid back within five years.
Cairn's shares fell as much as 11.4% on March 12 after it announced a further delay in the resolution of a tax dispute in India. They fell a further 3.7% on March 12 after Cairn stated the Kraken downgrade in its annual results release.
With American giant Exxon Mobil exiting the Dow Jones Industrial Average, it’s hard to imagine a silver lining in a bad year for the industry, but good news—very good news—might be just around the corner.
Fresh off the end to proration discussions in Texas, CEO Matt Gallagher shares how Parsley Energy is responding to demand loss plus the Permian shale producer’s focus on technology and ESG.
Even when U.S. benchmark prices return to $45/bbl, "very few" U.S. producers would be able to afford to expand production because of high debt levels, Pioneer Natural Resources CEO Scott Sheffield says.