Aboriginal and environmental groups will file lawsuits on Oct. 27 against the government of Canada to overturn the permit for a controversial $27 billion LNG project in British Columbia.
The lawsuits will name Malaysia's Petronas, which owns a majority stake in the project, as an associated party, representatives of the aboriginal and environmental groups told Reuters this week.
In September, Canada gave the green light for the Pacific NorthWest LNG project in northern British Columbia with 190 conditions, despite concerns it would destroy a critical salmon habitat and produce a large amount of greenhouse gases.
The decision was a major test for Canada's Liberal Party, juggling the needs of an energy industry suffering from job losses and the concerns of environmentalists, who were courted by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in 2015's election campaign.
The groups will file the lawsuits at the Federal Court in Vancouver, British Columbia. The lawsuit puts the future of the project at risk. It has already received a three-year delay in getting its environmental permit,and Asian LNG prices have dropped by about two-thirds since 2014.
The Canadian government was not available for immediate comment outside regular business hours. Petronas did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
"We believe there are serious flaws in the environment assessment process," said Greg Knox, executive director of SkeenaWild, an environmental group filing one of the lawsuits.
Besides the defects in the environmental review, SkeenaWild also alleges that Canada failed to review the project's climate impact.
Knox said the project would be one of the largest sources of climate pollution in Canada, even if it met the conditions imposed by the government.
The Gitanyow and Gitwilgoots aboriginal communities have similar concerns, and said they will sue Canada for failing to meaningfully engage with them before granting the approval.
"They totally ignored whatever we put forward to them," on salmon destruction and climate change, Glen Williams, chief of the Gitanyow, told Reuters.
The Petronas-led project plans to liquefy natural gas at a facility in the district of Port Edward, British Columbia, about 1,600 kilometers (1,000 miles) northwest of Vancouver. It would then export about 12 million tonnes per year of LNG to consumers in Asia.
Firms in China, India, Japan and Brunei are minority stakeholders in the project.
Enbridge Precedent
Both groups said they are confident of a decision in their favor, especially after the approval for Enbridge Inc.'s Northern Gateway oil pipeline was overturned in June. The Federal Court of Appeal said the government failed in its duty to consult with aboriginal groups.
Canada's former Conservative government in 2014 approved Northern Gateway. But after the approval, lawsuits were filed seeking to overturn the decision.
Gitanyow leader Williams said they are relying on the Enbridge case for a positive ruling. "[The lawsuits] put the project at extreme risk," he said.
Petronas is weighing its options given soft LNG prices and a weakening economic basis for the project, Reuters reported in September. Sources said Petronas is considering selling its majority stake, though Petronas denied it was mulling such an action.
Dwight Newman, Canada Research Chair of Indigenous Rights at the University of Saskatchewan, said while the case is before the court, Petronas would need to consider whether it wants to proceed with the project if there is a decision against them.
"The indigenous claims are tending to see more success [than the environmental claims] but in part, that's because the law is less defined and because indigenous communities have constitutional rights," he said.
Recommended Reading
TGS, SLB to Conduct Engagement Phase 5 in GoM
2024-02-05 - TGS and SLB’s seventh program within the joint venture involves the acquisition of 157 Outer Continental Shelf blocks.
StimStixx, Hunting Titan Partner on Well Perforation, Acidizing
2024-02-07 - The strategic partnership between StimStixx Technologies and Hunting Titan will increase well treatments and reduce costs, the companies said.
Forum Energy Signs MOU to Develop Electric ROV Thrusters
2024-03-13 - The electric thrusters for ROV systems will undergo extensive tests by Forum Energy Technologies and SAFEEN Survey & Subsea Services.
Axis Energy Deploys Fully Electric Well Service Rig
2024-03-13 - Axis Energy Services’ EPIC RIG has the ability to run on grid power for reduced emissions and increased fuel flexibility.
TotalEnergies Rolling Out Copilot for Microsoft 365
2024-02-27 - TotalEnergies’ rollout is part of the company’s digital transformation and is intended to help employees solve problems more efficiently.