Commissioners on a Minnesota regulatory board questioned crude oil demand for Enbridge Inc.'s (NYSE: ENB) Line 3 pipeline on June 26, ahead of an expected decision this week on whether work can proceed on a proposed expansion of the line.
Enbridge wants to replace the aging 1,031-mile (1,660-km) pipeline that runs from Alberta to Wisconsin, but it needs approval from the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, which must decide whether the project is needed, and the route.
Bottlenecks in Alberta have steepened a price discount for its heavy crude this year.
Line 3, placed into service in 1968, operates at half its capacity due to integrity concerns. Its replacement would allow it to return to approved capacity of 760,000 barrels per day (bbl/d).
Commissioners spent part of the morning discussing whether the project is necessary.
Commissioner Dan Lipschultz said he felt "frustration" having to rely on forecasts provided by Enbridge based on rising oil production, rather than on refiners' demand.
Enbridge lawyer Eric Swanson noted that global demand is growing, and that Enbridge apportions demand on Line 3—transporting less oil than shippers request.
“We think it shows a compelling case that Line 3 plus the expansion will be fully utilized," he said.
Lipschultz asked Swanson whether it would be reasonable to approve Line 3 for lesser capacity of 500,000 bbl/d, to which Swanson said 'no.'
Commissioner Matt Schuerger said data for state refineries suggest little idle capacity, although the state's largest refiner, Flint Hills Resources LP, has said Line 3 is badly needed.
“They’re getting oil clearly,” Schuerger said.
"The oil is getting to market somehow," replied Swanson, representing Enbridge. "The question is what is the most reliable, efficient means of getting it there."
Environmental groups and some indigenous communities oppose the project over concerns about spills and damage to tribal wild rice harvesting areas. Business and labor groups say the project, to cost $2.5 billion in Minnesota, would create jobs and tax revenue.
Recommended Reading
BP Restructures, Reduces Executive Team to 10
2024-04-18 - BP said the organizational changes will reduce duplication and reporting line complexity.
ProPetro to Provide eFrac Services to Exxon’s Permian Operations
2024-04-29 - ProPetro has entered a three-year agreement to provide electric hydraulic fracturing services for Exxon Mobil’s operations in the Permian Basin.
TotalEnergies Eyes Suriname FID by Year-end 2024
2024-04-29 - France’s TotalEnergies and U.S. partner APA Corp. look to place their long lead orders ahead of a final investment decision related to their joint development offshore Suriname in Block 58.
Kimmeridge Fast Forwards on SilverBow with Takeover Bid
2024-03-13 - Investment firm Kimmeridge Energy Management, which first asked for additional SilverBow Resources board seats, has followed up with a buyout offer. A deal would make a nearly 1 Bcfe/d Eagle Ford pureplay.
M4E Lithium Closes Funding for Brazilian Lithium Exploration
2024-03-15 - M4E’s financing package includes an equity investment, a royalty purchase and an option for a strategic offtake agreement.