Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Feb. 21 demanded aboriginal groups lift damaging rail blockades but the protesters at the heart of the standoff remained defiant, saying their conditions had not yet been met.
"The situation as it currently stands is unacceptable and untenable... the barricades need to come down now," Trudeau told reporters after some two weeks of stoppages that have triggered railroad layoffs and shortages of goods like propane.
"The injunctions must be obeyed and the barriers must come down," he said, adding later "the onus" for a negotiated outcome was on the indigenous leadership.
Given the history of violent clashes between police and indigenous peoples, Trudeau had been insisting on a peaceful, negotiated solution. But his remarks on Feb. 21 were a notable hardening in tone, signaling that police could soon clear the tracks.
Protesters have blocked lines in Ontario, Quebec and Alberta in solidarity with a British Columbia aboriginal band seeking to stop the construction of a gas pipeline over its land.
The hereditary chiefs of that band, the Wet'suwet'en, spoke alongside Tyendinaga Mohawk protesters who have been blocking a Canadian National Railway Co. line in eastern Canada near Belleville, Ontario.
"We heard Prime Minister Trudeau just a little while ago talking about the inconvenience Canada has suffered. However, there is a difference between inconvenience and injustice," said Wet'suwet'en Nation Hereditary Chief Woos.
Woos said the primary condition needed to pave the way for talks, which is that federal Royal Canadian Mounted Police leave their lands, had not been met. Another demand was that construction of the pipeline be stopped.
"If they show respect, definitely we'll start talking," Woos added.
CN Rail obtained a court injunction against the protesters on Feb. 7 but the Ontario Provincial Police so far has declined to act, citing the complexity of the situation.
The federal government cannot give orders to police forces, and Trudeau ruled out sending in the military.
"The intervention in the case of the [Belleville] blockade is the responsibility of the Ontario Provincial Police," Trudeau said.
Although Trudeau's message that time was running out seemed clear, the official opposition Conservative party criticized him for being too cautious.
"Justin Trudeau has already taken force off the table... now he is relying on the goodwill of the protesters to take down the barricades," Conservative leader Andrew Scheer said. "This is nothing more than phony resolve."
Recommended Reading
Energy Transfer Asks FERC to Weigh in on Williams Gas Project
2024-04-08 - Energy Transfer's filing continues the dispute over Williams’ development of the Louisiana Energy Gateway.
Venture Global Acquires Nine LNG-powered Vessels
2024-03-18 - Venture Global plans to deliver the vessels, which are currently under construction in South Korea, starting later this year.
Kinder Morgan Sees Need for Another Permian NatGas Pipeline
2024-04-18 - Negative prices, tight capacity and upcoming demand are driving natural gas leaders at Kinder Morgan to think about more takeaway capacity.
Ozark Gas Transmission’s Pipeline Supply Access Project in Service
2024-04-18 - Black Bear Transmission’s subsidiary Ozark Gas Transmission placed its supply access project in service on April 8, providing increased gas supply reliability for Ozark shippers.
Wayangankar: Golden Era for US Natural Gas Storage – Version 2.0
2024-04-19 - While the current resurgence in gas storage is reminiscent of the 2000s —an era that saw ~400 Bcf of storage capacity additions — the market drivers providing the tailwinds today are drastically different from that cycle.