HOUSTON—The clean energy landscape in the U.S. is poised to transform, boosted by policy support, but it will take collaboration to reach net-zero goals, energy experts said.
The energy transition took centerstage recently as executives from Baker Hughes Co. and Shell Plc joined experts from the Clean Air Task Force (CATF) and Wood Mackenzie to discuss low-carbon energy technologies and strategies. The K Carpenter Associates event took place after the U.S. accelerated its emission-reduction efforts, signing into law the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and its nearly $370 billion in incentives for clean energy and climate-related spending.
“It’s an extremely big deal, and it now cements the U.S. as a real leader in decarbonization,” said David Brown, head of Americas energy scenarios and technologies for Wood Mackenzie. “The next stage is about actually getting some of these projects that run around low carbon [such as] hydrogen, … and there’s a lot of capital that’s looking for investment opportunities as we speak.”
Current Clean Energy Landscape
Carbon capture, utilization and storage (CCUS), low-carbon power generation, new supply chains for battery raw materials along with hydrogen are among the key elements in the IRA, making it a comprehensive package to scale investments, Brown said.
Looking at CCUS, Wood Mackenzie estimates about 15 million tons of capacity could go online in the U.S. in the next 12 to 18 months. Favorable locations for development include areas with access to existing CO₂ and refining infrastructure, power markets and offshore storage as well as proximity to emissions—elements that put the Gulf Coast of Louisiana and Texas at an advantage.
There are nearly 120 carbon capture projects and activity in development, including four by Talos Energy Inc. in Texas and Louisiana, according to data from the CATF.
“The potential for CCUS is certainly there in the United States. Fifteen million tons is in the ballpark of what we think is realistic short-term,” Brown said, but it’s still very early days for that value chain.”
It’s also still “very early days” for hydrogen development in the U.S.
Wood Mackenzie estimates between 15 and 18 hydrogen projects in the U.S. could reach a final investment decision within the next year to 18 months.
“But that’s not a lot of projects. That’s less than 2 million tonnes of hydrogen, which is a really small amount of the energy mix right now,” he said, describing hydrogen’s value chain as “relatively weak” at the moment given all of the components that need to align for a project to be successful. These include offtake agreements, proximity to renewable sources for green hydrogen and natural gas prices for blue hydrogen, which Brown said needs to fall to about $4 or less.
Though it doesn’t require nearly as much investment as other decarbonization technologies, geothermal—specifically what CATF calls “superhot rock energy”—has potential and efforts are underway to secure additional policy and financial support, according to Philip Ball, chief of geothermal innovation for CATF.
Tapping ‘Superhot Rock’
Described by CATF as a “high-energy-density, zero-carbon, always-available energy source,” superhot rock geothermal mines harness heat from the Earth’s crust.
Water is injected five to 15 km deep into a superhot dry crystalline rock, opening existing fractures that allow the water to travel and gather heat energy, according to the group’s website. Steam energy produced is brought to the surface via production wells to produce power in electric turbines or generate hydrogen.
“The value proposition is there if we can demonstrate that all of the different components are working,” Ball said. “This will give us low-cost power; it’s low emissions and as the technology evolves, it should be globally available. It dramatically increases the footprint of conventional geothermal; it’s a scalable technology, and we think that has very significant attraction toward decarbonization.”
Geothermal technology is not new but there is still much to learn in the field.
Operations don’t always go smoothly, Ball said. He noted development of the reservoir and maintaining a steady flow of fluid is more of the challenge, not drilling.
“There are a number of innovations that are needed to make superhot rock happen,” he said, adding these include improving downhole tools, well construction, completions and reservoir development. Once these aspects and demonstrations, then commercialization should advance, he said.
Geothermal energy was among the technologies set to benefit from incentives, including tax credits, in the IRA.
“This is good [but] these are baby steps,” Brown said. “We’ve got a long way to go in order to get demonstrations in the ground and demonstrating power production through these technologies.”
Getting to the next level requires collaboration and partnerships, and different forms of energy will be needed as the world shifts to a low-carbon economy, panelists said.
“We need to continue to accelerate technologies like geothermal,” added Aura Cuella, vice president of energy transition for Shell. “We absolutely need to continue to progress all different solutions because different solutions are required in different parts of the world, even in parts of our country.”
Incentivizing improved efficiency should be another objective.
“The more efficient you are, the less energy we use and the more that energy can be repurposed, if you may, for different uses, and we need to use low-carbon fuels,” Cuella added before turning to the IRA, calling it a game-challenger. “It is really important to incentivize the use of these products because you can build as much as you want but if nobody buys it, guess what happens to that business?”
Fulfilling net-zero goals will require making necessary technologies commercially available.
“75% of the technologies needed for net zero are not available today commercially,” said Nigel Jenvey, executive energy transition for Baker Hughes.
The company is working to change that as it advances technologies targeting geothermal, CCUS, hydrogen and emissions management. Its efforts include partnerships, collaboration and investment.
To help scale carbon capture technology, Baker Hughes acquired this year Mosaic Materials, a direct air capture technology company. The company’s metal-organic framework technology, Jenvey explained, is porous solvent sponge that soaks up CO₂ from the atmosphere.
Cuella and Jenvey stressed the importance of collaboration, including partnerships with types of companies the energy sector doesn’t work with typically.
For Shell, this included partnering with U.S. Steel Corp. alongside Equinor ASA as the three explore a clean energy hub focused on CCUS as well as hydrogen production and utilization in the Ohio, West Virginia and Pennsylvania region.
“We are aiming to be a leader on the energy transition,” Cuella said.
She later added: “We do care about shareholder returns,” aiming for “profitable decarbonization.” However, “we need to make sure that what we do continues to respect nature … regardless of where we operate.”
2023-02-03 - Today's featured 25 Influential Women in Energy honoree is Allison Sandlin, U.S. onshore non-operated asset manager at Equinor.
2023-01-18 - Wood Mackenzie expects Canada’s largest natural gas producers — Montney Shale producers Tourmaline Oil, Canadian Natural Resources (CNRL) and ARC Resources — to continue to grow their unconventional production in 2023 despite inflation pressures.
2023-01-17 - Global capex will increase to $575 billion, which is well shy of what is needed to meet long-term oil and gas demand, analysts say.
2022-11-30 - Shale royalty Bryan Sheffield and Dick Stoneburner shift their attention to Australia.
2022-12-30 - Here’s a roundup of the latest E&P headlines, including a field start up and a well drilled to a basin with record depth from the past week in the upstream oil and gas industry.