HOUSTON — The advantage of having access to cheaper energy supplies is benefiting the U.S. economy to the tune of close to $1 billion a day, or roughly $350 billion a year, according to Francisco Blanch, Global Head of Commodities Research for Merrill Lynch.
Speaking at the Oil Council North America’s meeting in Houston on Oct. 9, Blanch calibrated an energy advantage — equivalent to 2.2% growth in gross domestic product — for the U.S. relative to Europe. With GDP in the U.S. growing at approximately 1.5% versus a negative rate in Europe of -0.5% to -1%, the net difference between the U.S. and Europe produces the 2.2% growth, he says.
Blanch described energy as “the main constraint on global GDP growth.” In the U.S., however, he noted that the oil supply/demand balance improved year over year by about 1 million barrels a day (bbl/d), as production grew by 750,000 bbl/d and consumption fell by 250,000 bbl/d. Blanch put the value of lower natural gas prices — “a tremendous benefit to the U.S. economy” — at $650 million a day.
“The amount of wealth and the support to the U.S. economy that the energy sector is providing is becoming a big eye-opener for countries all around the world,” said Blanch. Noting that the U.S. was expected to be a large liquefied natural gas importer six or seven years ago, “I just can’t imagine how this economy would be surviving at $18 to $20 per million Btu gas, which is what Japan and Korea are facing right now,” he continued.
Co-panelist Jan Stuart, head of Global Energy Research at Credit Suisse, was not expecting the U.S. to provide much near-term relief for Asian gas markets, with exports unlikely to grow to be much over 3- to 6-billion cubic feet per day, and the planned Kitimat export terminal in Canada viewed as “an end-of-the-decade story.” Asian gas markets would remain largely oil-linked, he said, and would depend to a greater extent on the pace of developments in eastern Australia and eastern Africa. In particular, Japan’s government and utility buyers would tend to maintain oil-linked pricing for security-of-supply reasons.
Blanch agreed that Japanese and Korean markets would remain oil-linked, given their lack of natural resources, but suggested the very large shale-gas potential in China would allow it to avoid paying the premium prices elsewhere in Asia. Currently, China’s natural gas price is around $6 per MMBtu — higher than in the U.S. but not by enough to markedly spur development of its domestic resources. Blanch predicted the Chinese gas price would over time rise to $9 to $10, but its domestic supply base would obviate it having to pay prices of $14 to $17.
On oil, Stuart said forecasts of rapid growth in U.S oil — including his own forecast of 10 million bbl/d by 2018-2019 — did not necessarily translate into bearishness on price. “We think it takes $95 Brent for the U.S. oil industry to self-fund the expansion that is currently under way to drive production up by something like 750,000 bbl/d per annum.” He recalled “the kind of panic that broke out in boardrooms” when earlier in the year West Texas Intermediate fell below $80 per barrel. Since then, he noted, the domestic rig count had largely flat-lined.
Below $95 Brent, “We simply are not going to get the growth,” he observed, “and I don’t think the industry can rely on foreign investors to supply the money willy-nilly like it has been doing in gas plays or the bigger oil plays.”
Recommended Reading
White House Open to Ending LNG Export Pause in Push for Ukraine Aid, Sources Say
2024-04-02 - Reversing the pause could be tolerable to the White House in order to advance Ukraine aid, in part because the pause has no bearing on near-term LNG exports, the White House sources said.
Segrist: The LNG Pause and a Big, Dumb Question
2024-04-25 - In trying to understand the White House’s decision to pause LNG export permits and wondering if it’s just a red herring, one big, dumb question must be asked.
What's Affecting Oil Prices This Week? (April 22, 2024)
2024-04-22 - Stratas Advisors predict that despite geopolitical tensions, the oil supply will not be disrupted, even with the U.S. House of Representatives inserting sanctions on Iran’s oil exports.
What's Affecting Oil Prices This Week? (April 15, 2024)
2024-04-15 - While concerns about the stability of oil supply are increasing, Stratas Advisors does not expect oil supply to be disrupted – unless there is further escalation in the Middle East.
What's Affecting Oil Prices This Week? (Feb. 26, 2024)
2024-02-26 - Stratas Advisors forecast that global crude production will be essentially unchanged from 2023, which means that demand growth in 2024 will outpace supply growth.