The once-brash U.S. shale industry, which spent profusely in recent years to grab market share, is now focused on preserving cash, putting it at a disadvantage to low-cost OPEC producers as the global economy begins to gear up again.
Prior to the pandemic-induced downturn, OPEC countries led by Saudi Arabia restrained their production, eager to bolster prices to fund national budgets dependent on oil revenue. Shale drillers took advantage, boosting U.S. output to a record 13 million bbl/d.
But attendees of the year’s top energy conference—CERAWeek by IHS Markit—made clear that even with a buoyant, $60/bbl oil price, shale will not come roaring back from the COVID-19 pandemic as it did from the 2016 downturn.
By contrast, OPEC and allies, known as OPEC+, has more than 7 million bbl/d of oil output sitting in reserve. This positions them to boost production much more easily than shale players for the first time in years.
The concern about free-wheeling shale companies taking advantage of OPEC’s output curbs led to a brief supply war in March 2020. Russia balked at a three-year agreement to extend production cuts, and Saudi Arabia responded by flooding the markets with oil, leading U.S. futures prices to slump to negative-$40 a barrel.
“Let’s face it. OPEC has had a very difficult time managing to accommodate the U.S. shale players and their ability to grow at low prices,” said IHS Markit analyst Raoul LeBlanc, adding that the key debate within OPEC is what oil price is just low enough to avoid a massive U.S. response.
The pandemic destroyed a fifth of global fuel demand, and numerous shale companies declared bankruptcy, while others arranged mergers to offload debt. Frustrated investors sent energy-related stocks slumping throughout 2020.
While shale executives expressed concern about reopening the wells too quickly, OPEC nations are expected to ease supply curbs at their meeting later this week, without having to look over their shoulder at shale.
“The worst thing that could happen is that U.S. producers start growing rapidly again,” said ConocoPhillips CEO Ryan Lance.
The market widely expects OPEC to ease production cuts, which were the deepest ever, by around 1.5 million bbl/d, with OPEC’s leader, Saudi Arabia, ending its voluntary production cut of 1 million bbl/d.
At CERAWeek, OPEC vs. shale is often discussed as a showdown between competing interests, but the dynamic of Texas vs. the Middle East is nearly invisible this year. Just one panel discussion in a five-day schedule focused on shale. Neither the Exxon Mobil or Chevron CEOs mentioned shale during their talks. Both companies have cut spending in the U.S. Permian Basin.
Crude on March 2 topped $60/bbl, up from $44.63 at the start of December, high enough to bolster U.S. producers' earnings given recent cost cuts.
In the past, rising prices have enticed shale companies to ramp up production even after they promised prudence, and $60 oil would have once prompted companies to rush drilling rigs and frack fleets back to work. That is not happening now.
“They are not taking the bait,” LeBlanc said.
Private companies are likely to increase oilfield activity, but not enough to meaningfully boost U.S. output, said LeBlanc, adding that U.S. spending is likely to remain around $60 billion, flat with 2020, as companies prioritize shareholder returns.
“The severe drop in activity in the U.S. along with the high decline rates of shale and the pressure from investment community to maintain discipline instead of growth means in my view that shale will not get back to where it was in the U.S.,” said Occidental Petroleum CEO Vicki Hollub.
2023-09-18 - Rig counts are falling—a reflection of higher interest rates and labor costs that now affect drilling costs, moving break-even prices even higher out in the price curve.
2023-07-28 - Exxon Mobil and Chevron Corp. each reported declines in second-quarter profits as the U.S. supermajors even as they continue to pump the Permian Basin.
2023-08-09 - Coterra Energy has started to see relief in well costs on big-ticket items like steel, sand and frac crews, the E&P reported in second-quarter earnings.
2023-08-04 - U.K.-based energy giant BP Plc looks to deliver on two important fronts by 2025 as it brings online more hydrocarbon production and boosts LNG supply.
2023-07-26 - Range Resources is allocating its free cash flow towards debt reduction and maintaining flat production, the Marcellus E&P reported in second-quarter earnings.