The U.S. Chamber of Commerce on July 1 criticized the Mexican state-owned power utility CFE's filing with an international court to begin arbitration with several infrastructure companies over pipeline contracts, saying the move could undermine investor confidence.
The CFE said last week it would aim to negotiate a "fairer" outcome to contract disputes with several companies through a mediation process overseen by the London Court of International Arbitration.
The infrastructure firms include Mexican companies Fermaca, Grupo Carso and IEnova, a subsidiary of U.S.-based Sempra Energy, as well as Canada's TC Energy Corp.
The London arbitration court could not immediately be reached for comment.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce said in a statement on July 1 that it was concerned by the move, stressing the importance of legal certainty to secure foreign investment.
"This action risks sending a negative signal to U.S. and other international investors about the business and investment climate in Mexico," the group said. "We therefore urge CFE and the Government of Mexico to reconsider this decision and to observe the president's pledge to honor the sanctity of existing contracts."
The group did not detail what action it wanted CFE to take.
CFE began talks with pipeline builder Fermaca on July 1 as part of a push to negotiate independently with the companies, CFE spokesman Luis Bravo said.
"All the companies have agreed to talk about the contracts. Today we met with Fermaca to determine how to negotiate," CFE spokesman Luis Bravo said. The talks will take place in parallel to the process in international arbitration court, he added.
Fermaca could not be reached for comment.
Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador has pushed back against criticism of the arbitration request, saying the terms of the agreements were "abusive" toward the state.
The U.S. chamber has repeatedly come to Mexico's defense during President Trump's administration, defending the North American Free Trade Agreement when Trump threatened to kill the deal and urging the United States to exempt Mexico and Canada from steel and aluminum tariffs.
The CFE's pursuit of arbitration has sparked criticism from others in the international community. Canada raised concerns about the dispute, and Moody's said the spat was "credit-negative" for the utility, the companies involved and the sector as a whole.
Recommended Reading
Tesla to Pause Plans for a Mexican Plant, Impacting Mexico's Nearshoring Appeal
2024-07-25 - Tesla, which announced plans in 2023 to build a $5 billion gigafactory in northern Mexico, is now pausing development activities until after the U.S. presidential election, its CEO Elon Musk said during the EV maker’s second quarter 2024 webcast.
Bipartisan Bill Aims to Speed Up Permitting Bureaucracy
2024-07-23 - If passed, the new rules would tackle litigation delays for energy projects across all sectors, an analyst says.
Texas Selects 17 Power Projects to Advance in New Loan Program
2024-09-04 - The 17 proposed projects would add 9,781 megawatts in power generation to the electric grid and will be distributed throughout the state, with four located in the Permian Basin.
Belcher: How Overturning the Chevron Deference Will Impact Energy Regs
2024-08-20 - The decision will enable the industry to challenge an array of federal regulatory actions.
Industry Warns Ruling Could Disrupt GoM Oil, Gas Production
2024-09-12 - The energy industry slammed a reversal on a 2020 biological opinion that may potentially put an indefinite stop to oil and gas operations in the Gulf of Mexico—by December.