Flaws in safety equipment and procedures used on Gulf of Mexico (GoM) rigs persist four years after 11 workers died in an explosion aboard the Deepwater Horizon that led to the largest offshore oil spill in U.S. history.
Drillers and regulators misunderstand the limits of BOPs, which are supposed to pinch pipes and prevent oil and natural gas from escaping a well in an emergency, the U.S Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board said in a report made public June 5. The BOPs on BP’s Macondo well failed, causing millions of gallons of oil to spew into the GoM in April 2010.
Industry practice and federal safety rules currently in place in the GoM may not prevent another catastrophic spill, according to the report. U.S. regulations fall short of standards used for drilling off the coasts of Norway, Australia and the U.K., which require more rigorous, regular and independent safety-equipment checks, the agency said.
“Vital aspects of effective safety critical element management have not been established in the U.S. offshore,” the report concluded. “Deficiencies identified during the failure analysis of the Deepwater Horizon BOP could still remain undetected in BOPs currently being deployed to well heads.”
Each system in the five-story-tall BOP must be tested individually so that a properly operating backup system doesn’t mask failure of another, according to the report. A pre-deployment test of the Deepwater Horizon BOP failed to reveal that two backup systems were wired improperly, investigators said.
Government reaction
The government halted deepwater exploration drilling in the GoM for five months after the Macondo disaster. The agency that oversaw offshore drilling was split to improve safety and enforcement and regulations were strengthened to prevent recurrence.
“There’s nothing here that hasn’t already been exhaustively addressed by regulators and the industry,” Brian Straessle, a spokesman for industry group the American Petroleum Institute, said in an e-mail. “The report ignores the tremendous strides made to enhance the safety of offshore operations.”
The safety board, which typically investigates chemical and refinery disasters, found that well-control manuals still in use by BP and Transocean Ltd. recommend a procedure that can cause drill pipe to buckle and jam the blowout preventer, as happened at Macondo.
BP costs
“We respectfully disagree with other findings in the report, including and especially the CSB’s assertions regarding Transocean’s operational and safety culture,” Lou Colasuonno, a spokesman for Transocean, said in a statement. Ellen Moskowitz, a spokeswoman for London-based BP, didn’t immediately respond to an e-mailed request for comment.
BP booked $42.7 billion of expenses after the blowout aboard Transocean Ltd.’s drilling rig. Last month, the London- based company lost an appeal seeking to erase disputed payments connected to a $9.2 billion settlement with most private parties. It still faces as-yet unassessed fines for the spill and environmental damage.
The report was done at the request of House lawmakers to probe the causes of the Macondo disaster.
Recommended Reading
Permian M&A: Oxy Shops Delaware Assets, Family Oil Cos. Stand Out
2024-05-10 - As operators scour the Permian Basin for M&A opportunities, they’re keeping an eye on a tepid divestiture market. Family-owned oil companies also stand out among the pack of private inventory holders remaining in the Permian, according to Enverus Intelligence Research.
GeoPark, Vitol Sign Offtake Deal for Llanos 34 Block
2024-05-10 - Under the agreement, GeoPark will sell and deliver to Vitol a minimum of 20,000 bbl/d of oil from the Llanos 34 Block in Colombia, which GeoPark holds 45% working interest.
Magnolia Bolts-on 27,000 Acres in South Texas’ Giddings Field
2024-05-09 - Magnolia Oil & Gas said it paid $125 million to a private operator to acquire the acreage, which has minimal production.
Tetra Tech Acquires Convergence Controls & Engineering
2024-05-09 - Tetra Tech is acquiring Convergence Controls & Engineering to expand its digital water and energy offerings.
Kinetik Launches Delaware Basin M&A Valued at $1.3B
2024-05-09 - Kinetik Holdings will buy Durango Permian infrastructure for $765 million, excluding contingency payments, and sell its interests in the Gulf Coast Express pipeline to AcrLight Capital Partners for $540 million.