Hedge fund Canyon Capital Advisors has warned it would vote against the $2.38 billion sale of offshore driller Rowan Cos. Plc (NYSE: RDC) to rival Ensco Plc (NYSE: ESV), casting doubt on a combination that had signaled optimism about the future of offshore exploration.
U.S. crude oil prices have plunged by more than 30% since the deal was announced in early October, making offshore assets less attractive. At the time, oil was trading around $75 a barrel, a level that helps ensure profitability of expensive deep-water drilling projects.
Canyon holds a 6.3% stake in Houston-based Rowan, valued at more than $80 million, making it one of Rowan's largest shareholders.
Shares of Rowan were up 7.8% at $10.24 in mid-day trading, while shares of Ensco were up 7% at $4.48. Rowan's shares have fallen by roughly 50% since the deal was announced.
In a Jan. 4 letter to Rowan's board that was released on Jan. 7, Canyon outlined several reasons for opposing the merger, including Ensco's high debt and its older fleet of drillships that are geared toward deepwater projects. The hedge fund also said the deal undervalued Rowan and that the merger was the result of a "flawed sales process."
"Not only was the proposed transaction unfavorable to Rowan at the time the deal was struck, but subsequent market developments—including the significant fall in Brent crude prices amid global economic and geopolitical uncertainty—have made it even less favorable in our opinion," Canyon wrote in the letter.
The recent drop in oil prices has thrown other previously announced energy deals into question. Last week private equity firm ArcLight Capital Partners LLC lowered its offer price for pipeline company American Midstream Partners LP (NYSE: AMID) to $4.50 per common unit from $6.10.
Ensco holds more than $5 billion in long-term debt, twice as much as Rowan, with nearer-term maturities and less available cash, adding risk to Rowan shareholders, Canyon said in its letter.
Rowan said the combination would create a "uniquely positioned offshore drilling company with capabilities across all water depths."
"We are confident that this transaction is the best way to maximize value for all Rowan shareholders," a company spokesman added.
Rating firm Moody's Investors Service last month said the risk of downgrades remains elevated for offshore drillers, including Ensco and Rowan, as they face significant contract expirations, weakening earnings and increased financial leverage through 2019.
Ensco did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Overall, 2018 was the Year of Consolidation as several E&Ps agreed to merge throughout the U.S., including inside and outside the prolific Permian Basin.
Activist investor Elliott Management offered to buy oil and gas producer QEP Resources in an all-cash deal valued at $2.07 billion, saying that the company is "deeply undervalued."
DEA Deutsche Erdoel agreed to buy independent Mexican company Sierra Oil and Gas at a time of growing uncertainty over the private sector's role in Mexico's oil industry.