For the second time this month, the West Virginia Supreme Court ruled on surface rights disputes between landowners and E&Ps. On June 10, the court upheld a lower court ruling in a case against Antero Resources Corp. that threw out a collection of lawsuits arguing Antero’s operation in the Cherry Camp area had created a nuisance.
However, the 3-2 decision did not include any new points of law setting precedent for future cases, according to a report in the Charleston Gazette-Mail. The report said the court did not “fully close off the ability of residents to use the courts to limit the effects of West Virginia’s growing natural gas industry.”
The ruling follows last week’s unanimous decision in a case involving EQT Corp. stating that gas companies no longer may drill on one person’s property to reach gas reserves underneath adjacent tracts without permission of the surface owner.
The Antero case was brought by residents in Harrison County who did not have wells located on their property but attempted to argue the horizontal drilling underneath their property violated their surface rights.
In Chief Justice Beth Walker's concurring opinion, she specifically stated that the court “does not answer the broader question of whether the owner of mineral rights underlying Surface Estate A may or may not create a nuisance on Surface Estate A to develop the minerals below Surface Estate B.”
2023-02-01 - With the Lario Permian deal closed, Diamondback wraps up a pair of fourth-quarter 2022 deals in which it purchased private Midland Basin operators for a total of about $3.3 billion.
2022-11-28 - APA Corp. and TotalEnergies, joint venture partners offshore Suriname in Block 58, deemed the Awari exploration well non-commercial but are eager to start flow-test operations at the Sapakara South-2 (SPS-2) appraisal well, Houston-based APA reports.
2022-11-22 - New Fortress Energy agreed with state-owned Pemex for the continued development of the deepwater Lakach Field as well as deployment of a 1.4 mtpa FLNG unit to commercialize the bulk of the production abroad.
2023-01-23 - The joint venture between CGX Energy Inc. and Frontera Energy Corp. begins drilling in Guyana as the region becomes an oil exploration hot spot.
2023-01-08 - Hess Corp. CEO John Hess expects his company’s shale production in the Bakken to plateau at 200,000 boe/d in 2024 and remain steady for eight to 10 years and overall U.S. shale production to flatten in 2025 or 2026.