[Editor's note: This story was updated from a previous version posted at 7:45 a.m. CT March 9.]
Oil fell about 2% on March 9, extending the previous session's slump to prices not seen since an OPEC-led pact to cut production was agreed, as record U.S. crude inventories fed doubts about the effectiveness of the deal to curb a global glut.
U.S. West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude prices fell through the $50 a barrel (bbl) support level, with market participants unwinding some of the massive number of bullish wagers they had amassed after the deal.
The losses followed March 8's slide of more than 5%, the steepest in a year, after data showed crude stocks in the U.S., the world's top oil consumer, swelled by 8.2 MMbbl last week to a record 528.4 MMbbl.
But several analysts remained bullish on oil for the long term.
"Headline risk can capture the imagination of the market over the near term, but we see dips as short-lived, key buying opportunities," RBC analysts said in a note.
"Record high inventory levels are reason for pause, but we believe that the market is overly focused on U.S. stocks ... The U.S. will be the last of the major regions to rebalance stocks given that storage capacity remains abundant, cheap and U.S. shale is extremely elastic in a $50 per bbl price environment."
Brent crude settled 92 cents, or 1.7%, lower at $52.19/bbl. On March 8, the benchmark slumped 5%, its biggest daily percentage move in a year.
WTI crude extended March 8's 5.4% losses by 2%, or $1, to end at $49.28/bbl, the first time below the $50-mark since mid December.
Brent and WTI hit respective session lows of $51.50 and $48.59, levels not seen since the OPEC cuts were announced at the end November.
Both benchmarks, however, were still within a tight range of about $3-$5 that they have been trading in since OPEC agreed with other major producers, including Russia, to curb output during the first half of the year in a bid to lift prices after a two-year rout.
"I still think we will stick in a fairly narrow range with the current levels reflecting the average price for the remainder of the year and a bottom of around $40 and a top end of somewhere around $60," said Chris Gaffney, president of EverBank World Markets in St. Louis.
Options trade also reflected hopes that prices would recover. Two of the three most actively traded options in U.S. crude were the April $50 calls with more than 24,000 lots traded and the April $51 calls with more than 17,000 lots changing hands by afternoon.
"Given that we do expect OECD oil stocks to decline substantially this year helped by the large OPEC cuts and robust global demand growth, we consider the recent drop in crude oil prices to be a good opportunity to enter into bullish option structures," strategists at Societe Generale said in a note.
But drilling in U.S. shale has picked up, with producers planning to expand crude production in North Dakota, Oklahoma and other regions. The Permian Basin, America's largest oilfield, has seen output jump.
However, senior Saudi energy officials told top independent U.S. oil firms in a closed-door meeting this week that they should not assume OPEC would extend output curbs to offset rising production from U.S. shale fields, two industry sources told Reuters on March 9.
Marketed: Galley NM Assets LLC Delaware Basin Royalty Interests
2023-01-11 - Galley NM Assets LLC retained Detring Energy Advisors to market for sale its oil and gas overriding royalty interests in the core of the New Mexican Delaware Basin.
Marketed: Stephens Natural Resources Operated Stack Opportunity in Oklahoma
2023-03-10 - Stephens Natural Resources LLC & Stephens Energy Group LLC have retained Detring Energy Advisors for the sale of oil and gas producing properties, leasehold and related assets in Oklahoma.
Chord Energy Divests Multi-region Package, Heavy on the Permian
2023-01-18 - Chord’s Permian position spans the Midland and Delaware basins and the Central Basin Platform, with most of the company’s assets described as stable operations from conventional reservoirs and waterflood assets with horizontal development potential.
Marketed: Erikson National Energy Corporate Divestiture
2023-01-31 - Erikson National Energy Inc. has retained Sayer Energy Advisors for the sale of the company's shares, with properties consisting primarily of operated, high working interest shale natural gas production from several formations in British Columbia and Alberta.
Energy A&D Transactions from the Week of Feb. 1, 2023
2023-02-01 - Here’s a snapshot of recent energy deals including Diamondback Energy completing its $1.55 billion deal to acquire Midland Basin acreage and E&P Arena Energy LLC closing its acquisition of Cox Operating LLC's interests in the Eugene Island 330 and South Marsh 128 oil blocks.