U.S. investment fund Harbour Energy Ltd. formalized its $10.36 billion bid for Australia's Santos Ltd. on May 17 but failed to sweeten its offer, dashing hopes of a higher price and sending the oil and gas producer's shares lower.
A successful bid would mark the biggest takeover of an Australian oil and gas producer, but Adelaide-based Santos has indicated the company may be worth more because of recent gains in the oil price.
Santos shares dipped 2% to sit below the offer price, with analysts suggesting the company may reject the bid as too low. The broader market was down 0.3%.
"With only two weeks since the AGM where the [Santos] Chairman implied this offer was not sufficient, we would anticipate the board recommending to reject," Macquarie analysts said in a client note.
Santos said it would consider the offer, which had the same U.S. dollar value as a previous indicative bid from Harbour, and urged shareholders to take no action.
Harbour declined to comment.
The bid would give Harbour access to a recently revived company with a low cost of oil production and stakes in LNG in the Asia-Pacific, where demand is soaring.
While Harbour did not change the value of its formal offer, Santos said it had now specified it would pay cash to shareholders other than China's ENN Ecological Holdings Co. Ltd. and Hony Capital Ltd., which together own 15.1% of the company.
ENN and Hony would be able to roll their existing Santos shares into a new Harbour investment vehicle and get shares in that new entity, Santos said.
The initial Harbour offer was valued at about A$6.50, based on the foreign exchange at the time, but oil prices have risen about 17% since then, leading some analysts to say Harbour would need to raise its offer to A$7.00 a share to succeed. Santos shares were trading at A$6.20 on May 17.
Santos opened its books to Harbour in April after the private equity-backed firm returned with its fourth proposed offer since August.
Daniel Rice, former CEO of Rice Energy who now sits on the EQT board, addressed the elephant in the room earlier this month at Hart Energy’s Energy Capital Conference.
Denbury Resources and Penn Virginia mutually agreed to terminate their merger after the $1.7 billion cash-and-stock transaction faced difficult market conditions and shareholder opposition.
After the lost year of 2020, have private E&Ps and their sponsors had to rethink everything?