Oil rose on May 9 after Canada's most destructive wildfire in recent memory knocked out more than a million barrels in daily production capacity, but caution among investors prevented a return to late April's 2016 price highs.
The lost capacity is equivalent to well over a third of the country's typical daily production, and almost all of Canada's crude from oil sands is exported to the U.S.
U.S. crude futures rose 65 cents to $45.31 a barrel by 6:18 CT (11:18 GMT), having risen earlier by as much as $1.28, while Brent crude futures gained 40 cents to trade at $45.77 a barrel.
The fire, which broke out on May 1, has forced three major oil firms to warn they will be unable to deliver on some contracts for Canadian crude.
The impact of the production loss has been far more marked in the U.S. crude market, where prices for West Texas Intermediate (WTI) oil for delivery in July are now above those for Brent.
Investors now hold near-record high bets on a rising oil price, which analysts say might mean there is less scope for Brent to rally after having gained 25% in a month.
"Positioning has been already very stretched in the oil market ... Some must have taken the opportunity to exit, so that's one angle that momentum is slowing down," Barclays Capital commodities strategist Miswin Mahesh said.
"There is a slight fear that prices have recovered too quickly, and we risk repeating the same price trajectory seen around second-quarter 2015, where the rally slowed down the market balancing process," he added.
Canadian officials on Sunday showed some optimism as favorable weather helped fire fighters, driving the flames away from the oil sands town Fort McMurray, but there was no timeline for a restart of operations at evacuated sites.
"The market is close to balanced ... when we consider the large amount of supply offline in Canada and elsewhere, which could last for months," Morgan Stanley said.
U.S. shale oil output is in decline and production is also falling in Latin America, Asia and Nigeria, eroding a 1-2 million barrels per day supply overhang that pulled down oil prices by 70% between 2014 and early 2016.
Markets were also watching Saudi Arabia, the world's biggest oil exporter, where a government shake-up over the weekend included the appointment of Khalid al-Falih as head of the new Ministry of Energy, Industry and Mineral Resources.
"Changes in Saudi Arabia oil leadership only underscore the shift in strategy to one focused on market share over price," Morgan Stanley said.
Oil and gas companies should carefully review their contingent consideration and earnout provisions in purchase and sale agreements and be prepared for the reporting and valuation challenges that come with them.
Oil output at controversial assets to increase even as government seeks to cut emissions, Canada’s natural resources minister says.
Oil industry suppliers such as Oslo-listed TGS and PGS have been hard hit by weak crude prices during the coronavirus pandemic as energy companies rein in exploration and thus spend less on the seismic data.