Williams Cos. Inc.’s (NYSE: WMB) long-delayed Constitution natural gas pipeline from Pennsylvania to New York got another possible lifeline toward being approved after a U.S. court on Feb. 28 allowed federal energy regulators to give the project another look.
Constitution has been stuck in a nationwide battle between energy companies—who want more gas pipelines to fuel power plants and heat homes—and environmental groups and New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who want greater reliance on energy efficiency and renewables.
The U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) approved construction of Constitution in December 2014 pending other regulatory approval, including water quality certification from the New York Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC).
Williams applied for certification in August 2013 but withdrew and resubmitted that application twice, both times at the DEC’s request. The DEC ultimately denied Constitution’s application in April 2016.
Williams has argued to FERC and in federal courts all the way to the Supreme Court that the state waived its right to decide on the certificate by failing to act in a reasonable amount of time.
In other cases, FERC and the courts have ruled that a state must decide on a certificate within a year but have said that because Williams voluntarily withdrew its application, that one-year period did not count.
That was before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in January 2019 ruled in another case, Hoopa Valley Tribe vs. FERC, the state must still act within a reasonable amount of time even though the parties agreed to withdraw and resubmit an application.
After the court’s decision in the Hoopa case, FERC asked the D.C. Circuit to remand the Constitution case back to FERC for further proceedings. The court granted that request on Feb. 28.
Officials at the DEC were not immediately available for comment.
In addition to FERC, there may be another path to get Constitution built.
President Donald Trump’s administration, which wants more pipelines built to create jobs and boost economic growth, has warned that the federal government could overturn state decisions that block projects, citing national security reasons.
When Williams proposed Constitution in 2013, it estimated the project would cost about $683 million and enter service in 2016. Delays, however, have boosted that estimate to as high as $875 million, according to local newspapers.
Constitution is owned by subsidiaries of Williams, Cabot Oil & Gas, Duke Energy and AltaGas Ltd.
Recommended Reading
CEO: Coterra ‘Deeply Curious’ on M&A Amid E&P Consolidation Wave
2024-02-26 - Coterra Energy has yet to get in on the large-scale M&A wave sweeping across the Lower 48—but CEO Tom Jorden said Coterra is keeping an eye on acquisition opportunities.
Exxon, Chevron Tapping Permian for Output Growth in ‘24
2024-02-02 - Exxon Mobil and Chevron plan to tap West Texas and New Mexico for oil and gas production growth in 2024, the U.S. majors reported in their latest earnings.
CEO: Magnolia Hunting Giddings Bolt-ons that ‘Pack a Punch’ in ‘24
2024-02-16 - Magnolia Oil & Gas plans to boost production volumes in the single digits this year, with the majority of the growth coming from the Giddings Field.
In Shooting for the Stars, Kosmos’ Production Soars
2024-02-28 - Kosmos Energy’s fourth quarter continued the operational success seen in its third quarter earnings 2023 report.
The One Where EOG’s Stock Tanked
2024-02-23 - A rare earnings miss pushed the wildcatter’s stock down as much as 6%, while larger and smaller peers’ share prices were mostly unchanged. One analyst asked if EOG is like Narcissus.