Public relations firms go beyond their traditional task of marketing to help their oil and gas clients fight off climate policies and mislead the public about climate change, U.S. congressional Democrats said at a hearing on Sept. 14.
The House Natural Resource Committee’s oversight panel, led by U.S. Representative Katie Porter of California, held a hearing about the role of public relations firm in preventing climate action and released a report detailing “deceptive” and “misleading” tactics they use for their client campaigns.
The report, which was based on its review of documents like submissions for industry awards, said PR firms helped oil companies fend off climate policies and mislead the public about their green claims by “engineering astroturf ‘citizen’ groups to advocate for industry interests and defeat legislative proposals, and using unscrupulous tactics to sabotage genuine policy solutions and attack community advocates.”
PR firms declined to attend the hearing about whether they helped the fossil fuel industry spread disinformation about climate change, according to the House of Representatives panel holding the event.
“Of note, PR firms Singer Associates, Story Partners, and Pac/West Communications were invited but refused to attend,” Committee spokesperson Lindsay Gressard said on Sept. 13.
Gressard said FTI Consulting, another PR firm the committee is investigating, will not testify because it is working with the committee to turn in documents that the panel requested earlier this summer.
While public scrutiny around energy companies’ “greenwashing” claims has grown, the marketing agencies behind the campaigns have largely escaped scrutiny.
Hearing witness Christine Arena, a former Edelman PR executive who now works in social impact filmmaking, told the hearing that PR firm campaigns on behalf of oil companies no longer deny climate change.
“Fossil fuel marketers have shifted from denying or minimizing the science behind climate change to falsely suggesting that oil and gas are a central part of the climate-solutions mix,” she said in her testimony, adding that 60% of energy company ads touted a green claim.
Anne Lee Foster, another witness on the panel who led a ballot initiative campaign in Colorado to ban fracking, told the committee about how local oil companies used a PR firm to create local citizens groups to counter fracking opponents and prevent them from get support for their petition.
“I personally suffered from what I feel is stalking or harassment in a number of other circumstances throughout this campaign,” she said.
Republicans on the panel have criticized the hearing and said that advertising and public relations are out of the natural resource committee’s jurisdiction.
Colorado pro-fracking advocate Amy Cooke, head of Colorado’s free market Energy and Environmental Policy Center for the Independence Institute, told the panel that she worked to oppose the effort to ban fracking in Colorado and said that supporters are entitled to “free speech.”
“We don’t have to raise our voices or shut down speech with which we disagree,” she said.
2022-09-22 - Talos Energy’s acquisition of private operator EnVen Energy grows Talos’ deepwater Gulf of Mexico footprint with the company anticipating subsea tieback opportunities.
2022-09-09 - Oil services company Baker Hughes reported that the U.S. oil and gas rig count fell for the fifth straight week the week of Sept. 5, following recent forecasts of disappointing oil output gains from EOG Resources and Pioneer Resources executives.
2022-09-23 - U.S. oil rigs rose three to 602 this week, while gas rigs fell two to 160. The total rig count fell in August and was on track to fall again in September after rising for a record 24 months in a row.
2022-09-15 - Dry natural gas production in the U.S. is forecast to rise slightly over the next 15 months or so to average 100.5 Bcf/d in December 2023 as rigs drilling for gas continue to rise, according to the EIA.
2022-08-12 - OPEC and the International Energy Agency (IEA) conflicting oil demand views, with OPEC cutting its world oil demand forecast and the IEA raising its demand growth forecast.