MIDLAND, Texas—The Permian Basin, that legendary gift to the oil industry that has kept on giving for more than a century, may be facing sustainability challenges that curtail producers’ optimistic expectations.
To determine the Permian’s outlook, merchant bank Parkman Whaling LLC first examined statements by the 26 public producers that are active in the basin. Those companies are responsible for the overwhelming bulk of production, and they saw a promising future.
“The public producers, at the time in the spring, thought production was going to double in the next three years,” Michael Hanson, a Parkman Whaling founder and Forty Under 40 honoree, said at Hart Energy's recent Executive Oil Conference. “So we’re going to go from about 2.2 million barrels per day [bbl/d] to over 4 million bbl/d.”
The more Hanson’s team scrutinized the producers’ plans, the less likely the team believed it could happen. There were simply too many barriers to the industry, particularly in the near term, to get the production to double within three years.
Hanson detailed four issues:
- Commodity prices had to rise to support the level of spending;
- Cost inflation would have to remain low so the premium locations producers were counting on would stay at a rate of return above 30%;
- Infrastructure would have to be available to take oil and gas out of the basin into the markets; and
- Capital must be available to the industry.
Hanson’s conclusion: “I don’t think it’s going to happen.”
Even if the Permian does not double production in three years, a remarkable leap even for such an illustrious play, there is still reason to anticipate rising volumes.
“Some stats here are amazing,” said Jay Boudreaux of Simmons & Co. “You look at 380 rigs running in the Permian. That’s more than the entire Middle East. This is an astonishing basin. You start peeling back the onion and see how much activity is going on here, there’s the analogy to which inning we’re in but I’d say that we’re still relatively early in this.”
Boudreaux sees decades of inventory left, with the Permian’s production cycle still in the proverbial early innings. Based on early talk with E&Ps about capex for 2018, Simmons anticipates another year-over-year increase in production of more than 20%.
The near-term sustainability issue doesn’t worry Boudreaux.
“I wouldn’t say [the basin will be sustainable] forever but as we continue to look at this, I’d say we’re relatively early,” he said.
But while the Permian’s prodigious reserves of hydrocarbons is unquestioned, the ability to continue to extract them economically over time raises concerns.
“From a subsurface point of view, I think it’s got great growth for a while,” agreed Raoul LeBlanc of IHS Markit. “The durability factor starts to get difficult, particularly if you have to increase your activity level to offset this big decline.”
Then there is a concern on the financial side about the effort it takes to sustain production. LeBlanc said markets were sensitive about incurring debt.
“What’s interesting to us is there’s an enormous difference between $45 and $55,” he said. For example, if costs are at $20/bbl and oil is selling at $45/bbl, then the margin is $25. But if oil sells at $55/bbl, that margin jumps 40% to $35.
“The reason U.S. production is so sensitive is because most of those wells are just going back to the base decline,” LeBlanc said. “We’re very sensitive to small increases in price because we put it all back and we can grow it, so how the markets go is very important to how things go in the next three to five years.”
Unlike most U.S. producers, Diversified, which this month changed its name from Diversified Gas & Oil, does not drill new wells, but buys mature gas fields and focuses on slowing their decline rates.
The divestiture primarily comprise natural gas-producing properties in the western Delaware Basin of the Permian and also include a small undeveloped acreage position, Callon Petroleum said.
Its latest pilot project includes a deal with electric and gas utility Xcel Energy to buy natural gas for its Colorado customers produced by Crestone Peak Resources and certified as “responsibly sourced” by Project Canary.