[Editor's note: A version of this story appears in the May 2020 edition of E&P. Subscribe to the magazine here.] 

The last few decades have brought impressive advances in production logging technology, especially in the context of new sensor designs and diagnosing com­plex flow downhole. Fiber optics also are playing an increasing role in production surveillance. However, the fundamental technique of using wellbore-confined production logging tools (PLTs) to infer total well and reservoir flow performance still dominates the industry.

Basically, PLT measurements are used to monitor fluid properties and flow dynamics in the wellbore and, more importantly, to determine production and injection flow profiles where fluids enter or exit the wellbore, such as via perforations or inflow control devices. These measured and calculated flow profiles are used to assess the produc­tion and injection performance of the entire well system.

However, the validity and accuracy of the approach depend on many factors, and chief among them is the integrity of communication between the wellbore and reservoir formations at the entry/exit points. Analysts and operators using PLTs must assume that fluids enter­ing or exiting the wellbore are flowing radially from or to the formations directly behind the entry/exit points. Unfortunately, this is often not the case. Flow paths can exist through annular cement channels, formation packers or natural fissures, and fluid will always find the path of least resistance. From a compliance, environ­mental and performance perspective, these unwanted flow paths are bad news. Decisions made assuming well­bore flow correlating directly to target reservoir flow can lead to complex reservoir and field management issues as well as compromised asset performance. From a diagnostics perspective, it is clear that analysts and operators cannot rely on PLTs alone to diagnose and manage well system performance—a more powerful diagnostic approach is needed.

True Flow System
FIGURE 1. The True Flow system combines four technology platforms within a common architecture. Each platform has a distinct role: Chorus locates and characterizes flow acoustically; Cascade exploits thermo-hydrodynamics to quantify flow; Indigo provides a host of complementary wellbore measurements; and Maxim is the digital workspace that analysts use to create programs, integrate and process data, and produce the answer product. (Source: TGT)

Seeing further

The challenge of behind-casing crossflow is not new, and the industry has made several attempts over the decades to diagnose this insidious phenomenon. Some of the early techniques used nuclear activation, chem­ical tracers and noise logging to try to detect and map flow behind pipe, but these methods generally lacked the precision demanded of modern-day diagnostics and were, at best, qualitative.

Operators have increasingly been focused on compliance, the need for better asset perfor­mance and pure ingenuity. As a result, a new diagnostic capabil­ity has emerged for diagnosing flow downhole.

Understanding the dynamics and connectivity of wellbore and reservoir flow downhole with any degree of precision and accuracy is a highly com­plex task that extends beyond the capabilities of conventional logging. This is why True Flow diagnostics utilizes a more pow­erful system-based approach. The system delivers a complete picture of well system flow dynamics and enables better-informed well, reservoir and field man­agement decisions (Figure 1).

Programs and methods

The first stage in the workflow is pro­grams and methods. Following an initial customer consultation, an analysis of well performance history, completion design and reservoir and fluid proper­ties, and an assessment of diagnostic objectives, analysts customize a survey program that will effectively “stress-test” the well system to expose its flow dynam­ics in a number of scenarios. This can be likened to a heart specialist exercising a patient on different treadmill settings while scanning physiological parameters such as heart rate, blood pressure and electrocardio signals. Typical programs will include a precisely timed sequence of flowing and non-flowing surveys that allow the entire well system to warm up and cool down between surveys.

Tools and measurements

The second stage is the application of high-fidelity tools and measurements by engineers that survey the well accord­ing to the diagnostic program. The measurements come from basic and advanced PLT-type wellbore probes and a combination of acoustic and high-preci­sion temperature sensors. Fluids flowing throughout the well system generate acoustic signals encoded with flow information. The acoustic sensing tech­nology used by the True Flow system captures this information in the form of sound pressure across a wide frequency and amplitude range.

Importantly, the dynamic range of this technology means it can sample absolute sound levels from deafen­ingly loud to imperceptibly quiet with­out losing clarity or detail. This means that a wide variety of flow scenarios can be located and characterized throughout the well system, from the wellbore to several meters into the reservoir formation. The temperature sensor in itself is unremarkable, being an industry standard fast-response, high-precision type capable of resolv­ing to decimals of degrees. However, correlating temperature changes observed during the diagnostic pro­gram and combining it with the acous­tic data, wellbore flow measurements and other well and reservoir informa­tion is the key to quantifying flow by the next ingredient of the system—processing and modeling.

Total Flow Answer
FIGURE 2. A typical Total Flow answer product derived using the True Flow system is depicted. The PLT-derived wellbore flow profile (left) shows oil and water entering the wellbore at P2 only, suggesting the source of production is from the target reservoir at the same depth. However, the True Flow system reveals that several other formation layers are contributing to this flow, including that the main oil production is coming from the A3 formation, and the water is emanating from deeper layers. By seeing the total flow picture, the operator has a more accurate and complete understanding of well and reservoir behavior and is able to target appropriate remediation. (Source: TGT)

Processing and modeling

During the processing and modeling stage, data acquired during the sur­vey program are enhanced further by analysts using a digital workspace and a number of processing and modeling plug-ins. High-resolution acoustic data are transformed into an “acoustic power spectrum” to reveal the characteristic signatures of different types of flow. Ana­lysts can select from a catalog of digitally enhanced spectra to illuminate particular aspects of the flow and extract maximum information from the acoustic signals.

The subsequent flow modeling is integral to the entire system and rep­resents another significant advance­ment in flow diagnostics. Precision temperature measurements acquired during all stages of the diagnostic pro­gram are assimilated together with all other data to derive reservoir flow pro­files. These are distinct from conven­tional PLT-derived wellbore flow pro­files because they quantify flow exiting or entering formation layers whether or not casing or perforations are pres­ent. Built on more than a decade of research and experimentation and commercially proven in thousands of wells, the flow modeling engine solves complex thermo-hydrodynamic physics by matching simulated and measured temperature and other responses in the flow scenarios created during the diagnostic program. The result is quantified reservoir flow that, together with wellbore flow measurements, com­pletes the total flow picture.

Analysis and interpretation

The previous True Flow stages are curated under the watchful eye of analysts that also administer the final important stage of the workflow—analysis and interpre­tation. Armed with all available well data, processed and modeled results, and expert knowledge of true flow appli­cations, the analyst will derive and compile the diagnostic result. While more complex scenarios can take a number of days to complete, the final result is a more compre­hensive and accurate diagnostic of reservoir and wellbore flow that ultimately leads to better well management deci­sions and improved asset performance.

The system is used to provide a range of diagnostic answer products that address most flow-related appli­cations. These products include Total Flow, which combines both wellbore and reservoir flow (Figure 2), Sand Flow for sand management applications, Fracture Flow to optimize fracturing programs, Stimulate Flow, Horizontal Flow and many more.

A bright future

The old thinking cannot answer today’s new challenges. As well systems become more complex and older, man­aging performance will remain a priority and continue to task the industry. Wells are built to connect the right fluids to the right places, safely and productively, but forces, materials and age conspire to undermine this perfect balance. Traditional production logging will continue to play an important role in managing produc­tion, but it is clear that the industry needs to look beyond the wellbore to the reservoir itself to see the true picture.