A U.K. High Court threw out a case brought by climate activists against the country's oil and gas regulator OGA on Jan. 18, rejecting their argument that the OGA's actions amount to a type of unlawful subsidy of the fossil fuel sector.
The ruling is a setback for climate activists who are increasingly taking to the courts to force a reduction in oil and gas production in order to control global warming, according to Reuters.
In the case, activists including a former oil refinery worker targeted the OGA's assessment of applications for oil and gas field developments on a pre-tax basis, noting in some years if oil and gas prices were low the government actually returned money to producers rather than benefiting from tax receipts.
This, they argue, is in conflict with both the government's long-standing policy of "maximizing economic recovery" of oil and gas in the British North Sea, meaning that oil and gas extraction there should make commercial sense, and with Britain's 2050 net zero emissions goal.
"I reject the contention that the strategy is unlawful because the definition of 'economically recoverable' was irrational. It follows that the claimants' claim fails and is dismissed," Judge Sara Cockerill said in the ruling document.
Britain's treasury received around 248 million pounds from oil and gas production in 2020/21, a drop of 71% on the previous year, according to official data, due to a plunge in oil and gas prices during the pandemic.
The Paid to Pollute campaigners highlight tax years such as 2016/17 when an oil price slump meant the government returned 400 million pounds to oil producers, rather than benefiting from any net receipts.
"We welcome the judgment. We remain firmly focused on regulating and influencing the oil, gas and carbon storage industries to both secure energy supply and support the transition to net zero," an OGA spokesman said in a statement.
OGA lawyer Kate Gallafent had told the court in December the benefits of oil and gas extractions were "a lot wider" than tax revenues, pointing to energy security and jobs.
The climate campaigners had no immediate comment on the ruling.
Recommended Reading
Oilfield Service Companies Dril-Quip, Innovex to Merge
2024-03-18 - Dril-Quip Inc. and Innovex Downhole Solutions Inc. will emerge as a new company, Innovex International, with expanded reach in global markets.
Talos Energy Sells CCS Business to TotalEnergies
2024-03-18 - TotalEnergies’ acquisition targets Talos Energy’s Bayou Bend project, and the French company plans to sell off the remainder of Talos’ carbon capture and sequestration portfolio in Texas and Louisiana.
EQT, Equitrans to Merge in $5.45B Deal, Continuing Industry Consolidation
2024-03-11 - The deal reunites Equitrans Midstream Corp. with EQT in an all-stock deal that pays a roughly 12% premium for the infrastructure company.
Continental Resources Makes $1B in M&A Moves—But Where?
2024-02-26 - Continental Resources added acreage in Oklahoma’s Anadarko Basin, but precisely where else it bought and sold is a little more complicated.
Permian Activity in ‘Low-to-no-growth’ Mode for First Half
2024-02-22 - After multiple M&A moves in 2023 and continued E&P adherence to capital discipline, Permian Basin service company ProPetro sees the play holding steady.